|
TOPLEA MACHINERY IMP &.EXP CO.,LTD
|
Product (155)
- Slaughterhouse Equipment (84)
- Poultry Farming Equipment (7)
- Cold Room (19)
- Rendering Equipment (22)
- Food Processing Equipment (23)
Poultry News (81)
Industry News (34)
Lay Out Reference (1)
INTRODUCTION TO THE POULTRY PROCESSING INDUSTRY (11)
Blog (23)
Cooperation company (9)
News (10)
Credit Report
Products Index
Company Info
TOPLEA MACHINERY IMP &.EXP CO.,LTD [China (Mainland)]
Business Type:Manufacturer, Trading Company
City: Ningbo
Province/State: Zhejiang
Country/Region: China (Mainland)
Follow Us:
Poultry News
US - A recently released video from an animal welfare organisation allegedly shows welfare issues at a broiler processing company. An independent expert panel commenting on the video explained the procedures shown and, while observing that some processes could be improved, they found no evidence for the video claims of "horrific animal abuse".
The Center for Food Integrity (CFI) has created the Animal Care Review Panel programme to engage recognised animal care specialists to examine video and provide expert perspectives for food retailers, the poultry industry and the media.
Panels include a veterinarian, an animal scientist and an ethicist to assure various perspectives are represented. This expert panel that reviewed a recent video from a chicken processing facility and posted online by the groupMercy For Animals was comprised of Dr Michael Hulet (animal scientist), Pennsylvania State University; Dr Chuck Hofacre (veterinarian), University of Georgia and, Dr Ruth Newberry (ethicist), Washington State University and the Norwegian University of Life Sciences.
Early in the video, the narrator states the hidden camera investigation reveals "horrific animal abuse."
"I don't see horrific animal abuse in this video," said Dr Hofacre. "USDA inspectors are on site. If they see abuse, they have authority to stop things.
"If people want to eat meat, we must kill animals. Some of the process isn't camera-friendly – it's not pretty. There are systems and processes in place to make sure it's carried out in a humane manner and I did not see animal abuse in this video."
Video claim: Birds are bred to grow obese so quickly that many of them become crippled under their own weight.
Dr Hofacre said: "This statement is inaccurate. Birds aren't raised to be obese and it would be highly unusual for them to become crippled under their own weight. If the birds were obese, that means they're putting on fat instead of muscle."
Dr Hulet added: "Birds did not appear obese in the video and legs did not appear splayed or the birds otherwise having problems to stand. After being raised on an organic surface of sawdust or wood chips, the birds are placed on an unfamiliar slick surface as they arrive at the plant and some need time to gain equilibrium."
Video claim: Sick and diseased, many birds are dead on arrival at the processing facility.
Dr Newberry commented: "The narrator says many of the birds arrive dead at the slaughterhouse but no numbers are provided. The percentage of birds arriving dead should be routinely monitored and should not exceed 0.5 per cent. Under best practices, if mortality rises above one bird in 400, the sources of mortality are promptly investigated and remedial steps are taken to correct any problems found."
Dr Hulet said: "Many times birds are euthanised at the farm and delivered to the plant in a transport coop to put into the rendering tank. DOAs average less than 0.5 per cent. If dead on arrival (DOAs) are greater than 1.0 per cent, an investigation is usually conducted to determine why and correct the problem."
Dr Hofacre explained: "There were some dead birds shown in the video but there's no context. There's no way to tell what happened."
Dr Newberry added: "Early in the video, two chickens are shown lying on their backs on a pile of feathers. One chicken appears to be dead and the other is breathing. The angle of the filming does not allow the viewer to see where the scene was filmed, or what transpired immediately before and after this brief clip. Any chickens found to be unfit for travel during catching at the chicken house, or discovered to be unfit on arrival at the processing plant, should be promptly euthanised and checked to ensure that they are dead prior to disposal."
Video claim: On arrival at the plant, the birds are callously dumped from their transport crates.
Dr Newberry explained: "A cage-dump system is used to unload chickens from the transport crates. A system that allows chickens to remain calm prior to slaughter would be preferred to minimise stress."
Dr Hulet said: "The example of positioning the transport crate seen in the video was rougher than desired but didn't appear to injure or distress the animals. Certainly, the company would not want the birds injured or the equipment damaged. This method of unloading birds from the transport crates seen in the video actually has lower wing bruises/breaks than other methods."
Video claim: The birds are quickly and violently slammed into metal shackles.
Dr Hofacre commented: "The birds are, indeed, quickly shackled. I disagree they are violently shackled. It's not appropriate to injure a live animal and there are federal inspection routines in place at all plants to make sure this doesn't happen."
Dr Hulet said: "Birds go along a 'breast rub' (a bar parallel to the shackles that the birds' breast rubs against which has been shown to have a calming effect) under low lighting conditions to calm them before they are shackled. No excessive flapping behavior was observed in the video after the employees quickly placed the birds' legs into the shackles."
Video claim: Broken legs and torn wings are common.
Dr Hulet said: "There are many reasons for leg problems but the birds in the video didn't show severe leg lesions or splaying. Statistics show less than two per cent of birds arrive at US processing plants with broken wings."
Dr Hofacre commented: "It's not common. It would be the result of improper animal handling and would cost a plant a lot of money. It's impossible to tell from this video the extent of wing and leg problems, but industry statistics show their occurrence to be low."
Video claim: Employees are urged to shackle sick birds alongside those intended for human consumption.
Dr Hulet stated: "Employees on the line are not trained to determine sick or unwholesome birds and that is why they are told to shackle all live birds. There are experts in the plant to determine wholesomeness and can condemn either the whole carcass or parts that are not fit for human consumption."
Dr Newberry said: "A chicken with an open wound is seen being shackled. In some audit systems, a bird with an open fracture would be considered unfit and would be euthanised rather than being shackled. I realise the employees do not have authority to make those decisions."
Dr Hulet explained: "For a wound such as the one shown, it would be proper to immediately euthanise the bird. Some processing plants have their crew trained in cervical dislocation at the hanging area and the bird would then be immediately euthanised. However, some do not have personnel trained and allow for euthanasia to occur by stunning and exsanguination, which is also a proper euthanasia method. The USDA and company personnel could then judge the wholesomeness of the carcass as the bird is processed.
"The wound evidently occurred after the bird was loaded, and I would prefer something be done immediately to lessen the pain and suffering of the bird when the injury is observed. This could be a point of discussion with the company on modification of euthanasia procedures. As has been mentioned before, this type of injury is definitely not a common occurrence."
In the video, a plant employee is seen talking about how birds with broken wings or legs can be salvaged as long as they are still alive.
